Westside Pioneer Home Page

ESSAY: Thanksgiving back-story is pilgrims breaking free of socialism

By Dr. Harold Pease

Nov. 13, 2017
       It has been said that the casualties of the 2016 presidential election were, in order, the toppling of the Bush and Clinton dynasties and the nullification of the Obama legacy.
       At the top, however, was the rejection of socialism. No two presidential candidates had been more socialistic than Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton, and
Dr. Harold Pease
Courtesy photo
half of America voted for socialism. Expanding Obamacare and instituting “free college” would have made it very difficult to argue that we had not become a socialist country. This is despite the harsh lessons of our socialist beginnings.
       On Thanksgiving Day, we see the image of the pilgrims enjoying abundant food, but this was not their full reality. They endured starving times the first year, 1620, when half their number died of starvation. Harvests were not bountiful in that year nor the next two. The Plymouth Colony was beset by laziness and thievery.
       William Bradford, the governor of the colony, in his “History of Plymouth Plantation,” reported that “much was stolen, both by night and day,” to alleviate the prevailing condition of hunger. The mythical “feast” of the first Thanksgiving did fill the pilgrims' bellies briefly, he reported, and they were grateful, but abundance was anything but common.
       Why did this happen? Because they had fallen victim to the socialistic philosophy of “share the wealth,” where people produce according to their abilities and receive according to their needs. This disincentivized the productive base of society.
       Then suddenly, as though night changed to day, the crop of 1623 was bountiful, and those thereafter as well, and it had nothing to do with the weather. Bradford wrote, “Instead of famine, now God gave them plenty and the face of things was changed, to the rejoicing of the hearts of many, for which they blessed God.” He concluded later, “any general want or famine hath not been amongst them since to this day.”
       One variable alone made the difference and ended the three-year famine. The pilgrims abandoned the notion of government (or corporation) owning the means
A cheering image of the Plymouth Colony pilgrims enjoying a feast so great they could share it with their Indian neighbors has come to symbolize the American holiday of Thanksgiving. However, the back- story that isn't commonly told is how the pilgrims, to achieve lasting success, had to wean themselves off of a "share the wealth" socialism that nearly led to their demise.
Courtesy of biblescripture.net
of production and distribution in favor of the individuals having property and taking care of it themselves. Before, no one had benefited by working because they had received the same compensation as those who did not.
       After the change, everyone kept the benefits of their labor. Those who chose not to work basically chose also to be poor, and the government (corporation) no longer confiscated from those who produced to give to those who did not. No government food stamps there.
       Ironically, all this could have been avoided had Plymouth consulted history and communicated with their neighboring colony, some distance to the south, which had previously gone down the same trail. Jamestown too was first a socialist society.
       Our textbooks tell us that only 1 of 12 in Jamestown survived the first two years for precisely the same reason as the Plymouth Colony: starvation. The problem, as noted by Tom Bethel in his work, “The Noblest Triumph: Property and Prosperity through the Ages,” was identified by an unnamed participant as “want of providence, industrie and government, and not the barenness and defect of the Countrie.”
       Captain John Smith is credited with having saved the floundering colony by his “no work, no eat” government program (here, the Virginia Company was the government), but was initially hated for it. Addicted to the promise of getting something for nothing, even if it is less than promised, the receiving part of the population will always oppose not getting their “fair share.” Sound familiar?
       Captain Smith was eventually carted off to England in chains as fast as the parasitic population could do so. Once again, why? Philip A. Bruce in his “Economic History of Virginia in the Seventeenth Century” called it agricultural socialism. “The settlers did not have even a modified interest in the soil… Everything produced by them went into the store, in which they had no proprietorship.” When settlers finally were allowed to own their own property, and keep what they produced, things changed over night.
       Jamestown Colony Secretary Ralph Hamor wrote of incoming prosperity, beginning in 1614, after ownership of land was allowed. “When our people were fed out of the common store, and labored jointly together, glad was he [who] could slip from his labor, or slumber over his tasks he cared not how, nay, the most honest among them would hardly take so much true pains in a week, as now for themselves they will do in a day, neither cared they for the increase, presuming that however the harvest prospered, the general store must maintain them, so that we reaped not so much corn from the labors of thirty as now three or four do provide for themselves.”
       This Thanksgiving let us be grateful for the prosperity that we have - even the poorest among us. Jamestown and Plymouth set us upon a course which recognized that prosperity requires incentive to flourish and that the profit motive stimulates industry. We are so grateful that, having recognized the poison of the “share the wealth” philosophy, those early settlers purged it from their midst and proceeded to make America the most prosperous country on earth.
       We remain mostly a socialist country, but the plunge deeper has been avoided for now and we have a chance to set a new course, distancing ourselves more fully from it, as did they. Will we be so smart? Let us share this message at the table as we feast upon turkey and pumpkin pie this Thanksgiving Day, so that our children will know how prosperity is produced.

       Dr. Pease is a specialist on the United States Constitution and its application to current events. He has taught history and political science for more than 25 years at Taft College. To read more of his articles, go to libertyunderfire.org.

(Posted 11/13/17; Opinion: General)

Would you like to respond to this article? The Westside Pioneer welcomes feedback to "General" items (to appear under this subcategory) at editor@westsidepioneer.com. (Click here for letter-writing criteria.)